Skip to main content
Questions & Answers
Categories
< All Topics
Print

What if my product fails?

If your product fails compliance testing, the laboratory will issue a Failing Test Report detailing the exact standards, chemicals, or structural elements that violated regulations.

Because you cannot legally sell a non-compliant product, you must pause production, isolate the issue, and re-test.

1. Isolate the Root Cause:

Review the laboratory report to identify exactly why the product failed. Failures typically fall into two categories:

  • Chemical Failures (REACH, RoHS, Prop 65): The report will show a specific component exceeding allowable parts-per-million (ppm) limits (e.g., a zipper puller failing for Lead, or a plastic cable failing for Phthalates). Cross-reference the failed part with your Bill of Materials (BOM) to trace it back to the specific raw material or component supplier.
  • Physical/Mechanical Failures (EN 71, ASTM, Electrical Safety): The report will state the physical hazard, such as a small part detaching during a toy drop test (choking hazard) or an electronic component overheating (fire hazard).

2. Implement Engineering or Material Changes:

Work directly with your manufacturer to rectify the defect:

  • For Chemical Failures: Instruct the factory to swap out the non-compliant material. Force them to provide valid component-level test reports from a certified third-party lab for the new material before they apply it to your product.
  • For Physical Failures: Redesign the vulnerable component. This may require thickening plastic walls, adding reinforcement ribs, changing glues, or altering electrical circuit layouts to handle thermal loads.

3. Draft a Corrective Action Plan (CAP):

If you are already selling older versions of the product, or if a major retail client (like Amazon or a big-box store) discovered the failure, you must formalize a CAP. This document proves to regulators that you have control over your supply chain. It must outline:

  • What failed and why.
  • The exact engineering or material changes implemented.
  • The quality control protocols added at the factory to prevent a reoccurrence.

4. Submit for Re-Testing (Retest Policy):

You do not always have to pay for a completely new test. Most major labs offer a Partial Retest Policy.

  • If a product failed only for Lead in a specific blue plastic component, you only need to ship replacement samples featuring the updated plastic.
  • The lab will strictly re-test that specific chemical parameter. They will then issue an updated, passing report by merging the successful historical data with the new re-test results, saving you substantial time and money.

How to Protect Yourself from Future Failures:

  • Hold Suppliers Financially Accountable: Insert a clause into your initial Supplier Agreement stating that the factory is financially liable for all laboratory testing fees, sample costs, and production delays if the product fails a Western third-party lab audit.
  • Implement Pre-Shipment Inspections: Do not wait for mass production to arrive at your warehouse. Have an independent inspector visit the factory to pull random samples from the production line and send those to the lab, ensuring the factory didn’t send a hand-made “golden sample” for the initial test.
Table of Contents